Doctor, Patient Expectations Differ on Fitness and Lifestyle Tracking

With apps and activity trackers measuring every step people take, every morsel they eat, and each symptom or pain, patients commonly arrive at doctor's offices armed with minutely detailed data they've been collecting about themselves. Yet health care providers lack the capacity or tools to review five years of Fitbit logs or instantaneously interpret data from dozens of lifestyle, fitness or food tracking apps that a patient might have on a cell phone, according to new research.

And patients who ask providers to make sense of their self-tracked data or spreadsheets are often disappointed by the reaction - or the lack of one.

In a study that won a best paper award that and will be presented in March at the Association for Computing Machinery's conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing in San Francisco, University of Washington (UW) researchers surveyed 211 patients and interviewed 21 doctors, dietitians and other health care providers about their expectations for how patients' self-tracking data should be shared and used.

"We've heard doctors say more and more that people bring this data into the clinic and they're just overwhelmed by it," said lead author Christina Chung, a UW doctoral student in Human Centered Design & Engineering.

"When you're managing chronic disease or symptoms, day-to-day lifestyle tracking data can be useful, but doctors don't have a way to use these data efficiently and effectively."

The UW team - which includes physicians, computer scientists and engineers - is exploring ways to make self-tracking data more clinically useful and to help health care providers and patients collaboratively engage with it, including:

  • Developing tools to visualize, summarize and annotate self-tracking data
  • Designing methods to help analyze and explore the data
  • Helping clinicians understand which tracking tools can best support different goals
  • Encouraging doctors to explain how they want patients to track behaviors, and why
  • Helping patients verbally explain or integrate information for their providers, rather than simply sharing raw data
  • Clearly outlining expectations for how the data will be shared and used by both parties

The researchers surveyed patients and providers who manage irritable bowel syndrome or overweight and obese patients - conditions that commonly involve tracking aspects of food consumption, lifestyle behaviors and symptoms.

Providers who asked patients to keep paper diaries or suggested specific tracking tools often found the resulting information helpful in collaboratively diagnosing triggers or arriving at effective treatments.

That was largely because those providers had designed and refined those processes over time to elicit useful information and track the most relevant patient behavior. Providers also found it helpful to make notes in the patients' paper diaries or forms, and then physically review them together. These notes also served as a record of the visit for patients after they left to go home.

Doctors reported being more challenged by data-tracking efforts that patients initiated. An app that a patient found in the Apple store, or wearable activity trackers like Fitbit or Microsoft Band suggested by a friend, may track extraneous information or summarize the data in a way that's not relevant for that health concern.

Co-author Jasmine Zia, an attending physician and acting assistant professor in UW Medicine's Division of Gastroenterology, said it's also important that the data be credible, which requires studies or validation that show a provider that they can trust the technology's analysis.

"As a provider you feel pressured because you want to help and interpret the data that people are bringing you, but every format is different and none of the data is validated," Zia said.

"One thing I'd say to app developers is that there really needs to be a summary page that's quick to look at and can be interpreted in two to five minutes. Right now patients just print out logs and that doesn't work," Zia said.

Patients, however, often become quite immersed in their personal data once they begin tracking it, said co-author Sean Munson, assistant professor of human centered design and engineering.

Patients who shared self-tracking data with providers wanted their doctors to have a complete picture of their daily life, to help them make sense of the data, to use it in developing personalized treatment plans and to be rewarded for their hard work in keeping those logs.

"Once patients start tracking data, they often see every day as a success or struggle. And people want their doctors to engage with it at that level, but that is totally impractical in the amount of time providers have," Munson said.

But interviewees reported that showing even a little bit of personalization and responsiveness to the data - whether it was looking at reports or listening to a patient interpret what trends he or she thought were important - could help build rapport and convince patients to follow through on the provider's advice. As one patient put it:

"He (the doctor) just skimmed through it very quickly ... but it was helpful in our relationship because I have some problems that were a little different than the normal patient. ... From that information, he went, 'Oh, this is a little different, we can treat this.' It made a substantial improvement."

The research was funded by the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services' Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality; Intel Corp., through its UW-based Science and Technology Center for Pervasive Computing; and the National Science Foundation.

Co-authors include Kristin Dew, a UW doctoral student in human centered design and engineering; Allison Cole, a UW assistant professor of family medicine; James Fogarty, a UW associate professor of computer science and engineering; and Julie Kientz, a UW associate professor of human centered design and engineering.

Most Popular Now

Kick-off Meeting for eHealth Hub: An Int…

The Kick-off Meeting of the eHealth Hub project took place on the 20th and 21st of October 2016, in Murcia (Spain). The meeting effectively launched the activities of a newly...

Read more

HIV Test Performed on USB Stick

Scientists have developed a type of HIV test on a USB stick. The device, created by scientists at Imperial College London and DNA Electronics, uses a drop of blood to...

Read more

Major Health IT Event Opens with Recogni…

21 - 22 November 2016, Barcelona, Spain. The World of Health IT (WoHIT) has opened its doors to over 1,000 healthcare IT professionals from across 25 different countries worldwide. Covering a...

Read more

Emergency Video Telemedicine Positively …

Approximately 10 percent of newborns require help breathing after birth, and 1 in 1,000 newborns require more intensive resuscitation measures. These infrequent, high-risk deliveries may present challenges to community hospitals...

Read more

Crack the Human Brain

The time is ripe, the communication technology is available, for teams from different labs and different countries to join efforts and apply new forms of grassroots collaborative research in brain...

Read more

EC Open Call SC1-PM-15-2017: Personalise…

The activity aims at developing and validating radically new ICT based concepts and approaches for empowering and motivating people in need of guidance and care due to age related conditions...

Read more

MEDICA and COMPAMED 2016 Provide a Power…

14 - 17 November 2016, Düsseldorf, Germany. Once again, the world's biggest medical trade fair MEDICA and the leading international supplier trade fair COMPAMED, which take place in Düsseldorf, have provided...

Read more

Open Call SC1-HCO-08-2017: Actions to Br…

Despite serious efforts deployed at national and European level, the European Union sees significant internal disparities in terms of research and innovation performance as also identified in the Innovation Union...

Read more

Chronically Ill Women Underusing Online …

Barriers to internet use may be preventing chronically ill middle-aged and older women from being as healthy as they otherwise could be, new research suggests. The study conducted by researchers...

Read more

MEDICA 2016 + COMPAMED 2016 with over 5…

14 - 17 November 2016, Düsseldorf, Germany. When top decision-makers in the healthcare business meet in Düsseldorf again in the middle of November at the world's leading medical trade fair, MEDICA...

Read more

The International Health Industry Comes …

14 - 17 November 2016, Düsseldorf, Germany. Decision makers from all sectors of the international health industry meet again in Düsseldorf from Monday to Thursday. The world's biggest medical trade fair...

Read more

Health at a Glance: Europe 2016

This publication is the result of a close co-operation between the OECD and the European Commission and is the first step in the Commission's "State of Health in the EU...

Read more
(HEALTH IT) SPACE - Take a look at who has just Joined